Future Features in Final Cut Pro X

Posted on by Larry

[ Updated April 18, 2012, to clarify some wording after a second conversation with Apple. ]

I had an on-the-record meeting with Apple this morning in Las Vegas, the day before the start of the 2012 NAB Show — along with a preview of future FCP X features, which I’ll talk about at the end of this blog.

NOTE: We also covered some amazing third-party announcements coming at NAB this year. I’ll have more on that later this week, after the NDA expire at a variety of press conferences later today and tomorrow.

SOME BACKGROUND

When Apple was preparing to launch FCP X, they told me that the new architecture of the software, combined with the flexibility of the Mac App Store would allow for much more rapid updates to the program. However, while the releases were planned well in advance, there is no significance to the alternation of feature (10.0.1 and 10.0.3) with, essentially, bug fix (10.0.2 and 10.0.4) releases. In other words, don’t read too much into this alternating pattern of features and bug fixes. However, do keep in mind that Apple has updated FCP X four times in less than a year since its initial release.

Apple stressed that FCP X is a long-term project and that they are fully committed to it. (In other words, because I asked, there is not a Final Cut Pro 8 waiting in the wings.) Apple views Final Cut X as the future of video editing.

Also, if you look at the features Apple has added since FCP X first released, Apple has almost exclusively focused on adding features for the professional market: Roles, Multicam, broadcast monitoring, etc.

I asked what the benefits were to using the Mac App Store for distribution of updates, and was told that the biggest benefit was that the Mac App Store license allows Apple to deliver both bug fixes and feature updates, unlike Software Update.

NOTE: The benefits of using the Mac App Store for updates to video editors are something I want to learn more about in a future conversation with Apple. I’ll have more to share with you then.

Apple also highlighted the workflow at Leverage which uses FCP X.

* The show shoots on RED in Portland, Oregon.
* Ships hard disks down to LA for editing.
* RED files are transcoded to ProRes Proxy for editing.
* The show is edited in FCP X
* X2Pro (from Marquis Broadcast) converts the files to ProTools for audio sweetening.
* XML exports from FCP X are sent to DaVinci Resolve for color grading
* Final conforming of audio and video is done in FCP X
* Final delivery is a ProRes file.

Apple also said the 10.0.4 update significantly improved broadcast monitoring performance, so they have removed the term “beta” when describing it. I specifically asked if 10.0.4 now has sufficient performance to support multicam monitoring and Apple said “Yes.”

THE GOOD STUFF

Then, Apple shared their plans for Final Cut Pro X features coming later this year (2012). Apple began providing “advanced looks” as part of the roll-out to the launch of FCP X and wanted to continue letting us know what’s coming. (I think this is a great idea, because it helps us plan.)

Here are the bullet points (none of this was demoed):

Audio mixing in FCP X is still weak. I’m looking forward to seeing what the new tools provide.

Dual Viewers is analogous to Source and Record monitors; though Apple stressed that when they implement a feature they try to do it better than it has been done before. A good example of this is their recent multicam addition. This feature would allow us to easily compare two clips.

FCP X has been able to read MXF files (think XDCAM EX), but not the native MXF wrapper that contains them. In the past, it needed to convert MXF to QuickTime. In the future, FCP X won’t need to make this conversion. Apple was quick to stress that this was not a move away from QuickTime, instead it was adding support for a common video format.

While Apple did not provide any details, I interpret “RED camera support” to mean that we would be able to edit R3D files natively, as opposed to editing R3D files as QuickTime proxies.

I asked when Apple would support retaining In and Out (Start / End) markers in clips in the Event Browser. They refused to comment, but stressed that while these were the four features they were announcing, these four would not be the only features released. Retaining Ins and Outs on clips is SO useful, I will continue to bang the drum for Apple to add these.

I asked if Apple would commit to WHEN these features would be available? They politely declined to speculate. (Sigh…)

SUMMARY

It was an interesting meeting. Apple clearly wants it known that FCP X should be considered a professional application, that development is on-going, and that they are listening to comments from users.

I tried to get them to provide hints on upcoming hardware, but no hints were provided.

I also got a sense they are working on another application to join FCP X, Motion, and Compressor. (There are several that would be very useful, we shall have to see what develops. I don’t expect anything announced immediately.)

All-in-all, it is always fun to meet the FCP X team and get a sense of what’s coming. And I wanted to share what I learned with you.

Larry

P.S. For the latest in Final Cut Pro X news, please sign up for my weekly, free newsletter: www.larryjordan.biz/newsletter/


108 Responses to Future Features in Final Cut Pro X

Newer Comments →
  1. Marcus Moore says:

    Thanks so much for the update, Larry. I’ve always felt confident that Apple’s intentions have been (and continue to be) misread, even if it was mostly their own fault…

    It’s a VERY un-Apple thing to pre-announce enhancements of any kind to any of their products, so I see this a a backwards acknowledgement of last year’s unfortunate FCPX launch- and an honest outreach to make sure that people know that they’re still invested in post software in a very real way.

    With 10.0.4’s performance and broadcast monitoring enhancements, I’m starting my migration to FCPX.

    Most of all, I’m glad that Apple acknowledged the importance of NAB, and didn’t sit it out on the sidelines while everyone announced new products.

  2. Tom Daigon says:

    Apple….to little, to late. Professionals are moving on to other platforms and software. Bye bye.

  3. Craig Seeman says:

    “I also got a sense they are working on another application to join FCP X, Motion, and Compressor.”

    Does Logic Pro X count?
    I know you can’t answer that since they didn’t give direct info . . . unless you know for sure that it’s something in addition to that.

    “FCP X has been able to read MXF files (think XDCAM EX), but not the native MXF wrapper that contains them. In the past, it needed to convert MXF to QuickTime.”

    “Dual Viewers is analogous to Source and Record monitors; though Apple stressed that when they implement a feature they try to do it better than it has been done before. A good example of this is their recent multicam addition.”

    I guessed that when I saw multicam. The pieces are in place for dual viewing and ganging. My guess is the one big difference is that it will be contextual in some form rather than always on.

    Hmm, XDCAM EX is MPEG2 in .mp4 wrapper in BPAV folder but I get the point and maybe they do mean XDCAM .mxf as well. I understand Sony will have a plugin for direct support in FCPX in the next week or so. I’m not sure if it’ll be doing a rewrap or something more like Cinemon.

  4. Marcus Moore says:

    No, Tom. YOU’RE moving on. I’m pro and I’m sticking around.

  5. Craig Seeman says:

    Tom Daigon, that’s why there were standing room only crowds at the FCPX presentations at NAB from what I understand. It’s not like NLEs cost $70k anymore. If there’s a good ROI on FCPX, you’ll find some facilities moving to it. There already are. I know of others besides Apple’s highlighed “in action” area of their website.

  6. Craig Seeman says:

    Marcus, I think Apple’s behavior acknowledges how big the mistake was on the marketing side. It’ll be interesting if they make any hint of these features to come on their own site. The fact that Larry can talk about this rather than under NDA is, in itself, big news.

  7. Bret Primack says:

    The only constant is change.

  8. Eric Emerick says:

    I just hope they realize how important the MacPro is to this market. It is true reality distortion to say on one hand that they’re committed to pro’s with FCPX and then cripple those same pro’s with iMac’s. High end graphic cards are very important to us and the inability to use them may be a deal breaker.

  9. Marcus Moore says:

    @ Craig … agreed. I think it was ENTIRELY a marketing mistake. An open timeline for the inclusion of features some workflows need is important to help those people make decisions. Unfortunately, without that information, the decision some made was to move to another platform. I won’t begrudge those people doing what they need to do for their business.

    But I think beyond a roadmap, a number of sessions at last year’s NAB, demoing FCPX workflow would have done a lot to stem the growing discontent that filled the vacuum of information between the NAB preview and FCPX’s launch June 21st. And really, what was gained? There were no huge surprises beyond what was demoed.

    By getting the user base to buy into the idea of FCPX as a future product, something some could use right away, and others could tinker with- could have made it more exciting than frightening.

    Larry’s not the only one who get’s a meeting with Apple- Scott Simmons will be meeting with Apple later today, and I look forward to his take on this.

  10. Tom Daigon says:

    Hey guys, if it works for you thats all that counts. It doesn’t for me and many others. Viva la difference!

Newer Comments →

Leave a Reply to Marcus Moore Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Larry Recommends:

FCPX 10.5 Complete

NEW & Updated!

Edit smarter with Larry’s latest training, all available in our store.

Access over 1,900 on-demand video editing courses. Become a member of our Video Training Library today!

JOIN NOW

Subscribe to Larry's FREE weekly newsletter and save 10%
on your first purchase.