[ Updated May 15, 2016 ]
Jeff Stansfield recently sent me an email asking for thoughts on how to create a good interview. This got me thinking about the articles I’ve written about interviewing: like this one about being a good host, and this one about being a good guest.
As I was thinking, I realized that an interview is not a conversation; it is a directed conversation. Always have a goal for every interview; even if it is only: “I don’t know what this is and I want to learn more about it.”
Always assume that your audience has not heard of the product or company you are discussing, but wants to learn more. This means that every interview – especially live interviews – needs to provide a basic understanding of the company/product/problem being discussed. Never assume that the audience knows as much as you do. It never hurts to cover the basics before jumping into “the interesting stuff.”
I just finished teaching a one-week class on creating mini-documentaries at the Anderson Ranch Arts Center in Aspen, Colorado. (They called it “Visual Storytelling,” I called it “Making Mini-Docs.”)
The class was divided into teams of three people and, each day for four days, each team would plan, script, shoot, edit, and export a four-minute documentary which was due the next day. (I’ve learned that tight deadlines encourage students to focus their thoughts on the task at hand.)
There were two key elements I stressed during the class:
Planning is not as sexy as production, but it is just as essential. When time is limited – and when is time NOT limited during production – you can’t afford to wander around trying to discover your subject during an interview. You need to have a goal in mind. This doesn’t mean you can’t explore subjects that arise during the conversation, but the best interviews are ones where the interviewer has a clear idea of where the conversation is headed.
In my mind, there’s a difference between planning and scripting. If I am interviewing an artist, I have no idea what they are going to say. But I do have an idea about whether my mini-doc is going to talk about his life, his work, his achievements, or his personal life. Because this mini-doc is only four minutes long, I need to focus my questions to get to the meat of the matter as quickly as possible.
Between my broadcast career and my podcasts, I figure I’ve interviewed on-camera or on-mic well over two thousand people. Almost all of them were not professional actors, but subject-matter experts who are rarely interviewed. Almost all of them were nervous. Almost all of them were convinced they would do a terrible job and didn’t want to be humiliated. ALL of them needed reassurance that, when it was over, they had done a good job.
Get all your tech checks done before the guest walks onto the set. MAKE SURE the mic is working properly and recording at good levels. (For my work, I record interviews around -12 dB.)
Before the guest enters the set, I’ve worked out camera angles, framing, lighting, and mic issues with the crew, so once the guest is on set, I just need to verify that the shot looks the way I want once the guest is in place.
Also, before the guest enters, we work out a subtle hand signal to tell the camera when to roll. Shouting “Roll ’em!!” may be satisfying, but your guest will instantly tense up. We also have hand signals to tell the camera operator to zoom in or zoom out, as well as warn the mic boom operator to get closer or farther away.
Once the guest enters, direct your full attention to them. Introduce the crew, then, let the crew focus on getting final tweaks made. As the interviewer, you need to build a relationship, a rapport, with the guest from the moment they walk in.
Explain the general process of the interview, tell them where to sit, where to look, and reassure them that they won’t die. (Don’t laugh. You’d be surprised at the looks of relief I get when I tell a guest: “And, you don’t need to worry. I haven’t had anyone die on camera…. this week.” They laugh, but they also relax.)
NOTE: I never share questions with the guest in advance. The guest will try to memorize answers, which always sounds terrible. I will share general subject areas, but never questions. Also, if a guest totally blows an answer, I won’t ask the same question again, the second answer will always be flat. Instead, I’ll ask the same question a different way.
I get the guest settled into their chair or location as quickly as possible, while continuing to chat about nothing in particular. This allows the crew to check lights, framing and levels without disturbing me or the guest too much.
NOTE: I can already hear readers saying, “But, Larry, I’m a one-man band.” Its true, many interviews are shot by one person. But I can say from experience that they won’t be as good from either a production or content point of view as an interview where one person is worrying about content and another person is worrying about the tech.
Asking questions is part art and part science. The art is really listening to what your guest is saying. Actors call this being “in the moment;” focusing intently on your guest and what they are saying. The science is in how you construct your questions.
The only way to really be able to listen is to write down key questions in advance. (I tend to write them exactly as I want to say them.) This means that in case I am listening so intently to the guest that I forget my next question, I’ve got it written down. This prevents me from panicking because I don’t know what I’m going to say next.
NOTE: I never hesitate to ask a question that seems relevant. And, if I get really lost, I only need to look at my questions to instantly get back on track.
However, I rarely ask my questions in the order I wrote them, and I often ask questions that aren’t written because they spring from our discussion. In other words, the written questions act as a prompt when I need it, but they are only a prompt, not a crutch.
NOTE: For a fifteen minute interview, I try to create about 18 questions. My general assumption is that it takes about a minute for a guest to answer one question. For live shows I use all of each answer. For taped shows, I select the best parts.
Just before the camera starts rolling for a taped interview, I remind the guest to include my question in their answer. More times than not, they do. And, in almost all cases, their parroting of my question is terrible. BUT, as soon as they repeat the question, they always pause, and, 95% of the time, the next words out of their mouth are a perfect start for the answer. I don’t know why, it just is. In 40 years of interviewing, I’ve come to depend upon it.
Once the camera starts rolling, I always ask the same first two questions:
Every guest is nervous and every guest feels that they are not in control of the interview. By asking this question, it helps them feel that they are in control, that nothing will happen without their permission, and, in almost all cases, I see them smile and relax. (By the way, no one has ever said “No.”)
Of all the softball questions, this is the softest. While I’ve had many guests stumble over their title, everybody has a pretty good handle on their name and company. By leading with something this simple, I get several benefits:
At this point, the interview dance begins. And I view it as a dance — I’m leading and they are following.
For me, an interview has an emotional arc, the same as a drama. I always start with easy questions which I never expect to use:
Simple stuff. Stuff they’ve been talking about forever. Easy questions with easy answers.
Then, I move into the WHAT, WHERE, and HOW questions. These cause the guest to describe specific problems, actions, behaviors. These set up a problem and what was done to solve it. I use these for the body of the interview. I also use “For example?” a lot during this section to drill down into specifics.
Then, I wrap up with WHY questions. These always elicit emotional responses. I never ask a guy a question like “How do you feel?” Very few men are capable of describing their feelings. But they are very good at answering questions like: “Why was this so important?” or “Why did you care?”
The secret code between me and my camera operator is that What/Where/How questions are shot on a medium close-up. But with Why questions the camera needs to zoom into a close-up, because Why questions bring emotions near the surface, where the camera can see them. Close-ups amplify emotions.
Sometimes after an almost-but-not-quite-good-enough answer, I’ll just ask: “Why?” and stay quiet. Generally, by this time in the interview, the guest is comfortable talking to me and wants to show that they are working with me to create a great interview. That solitary “Why?” causes them to reach down and reveal the emotional core that I’m after for the interview.
During the interview, I’m always listening for that sound bite that starts an interview and the sound bite that ends it. The first bite is almost always in answer to a What question. The closing sound bite is almost always in answer to “Why?”
QUESTIONS I TRY NOT TO ASK
I try really hard not to ask questions that start with:
Partly this is due to not wanting yes or no answers, which are uneditable. But there’s a deeper reason and it gets back to the goal of the interview that I mentioned earlier. Almost all guests want to please the interviewer. Its human nature. But they need to be told what would make us happy.
If I ask a guest: “Could you describe the problem?” they don’t know whether to simply say “Yes.” and wait for more instructions, or try to describe the problem. Generally, they stumble during the answer and you get a weak answer with no strong beginning or end and which is very hard to edit.
The way you ask the question determines the answer you get. Ask a wishy-washy question and you get a wishy-washy answers. The only exception to this rule is if the guest has been interviewed by so many ill-prepared hosts that they figure you’re just another dolt and they’ll give you the answer they want, regardless of how you ask the question. Politicians are past masters at this; so much so that it has a special name: “bridging.” Bridging means to “bridge” from the question you were asked to a different answer that you actually give.
At which point, you’ve lost control of the interview and the guest is running amok. I hate those situations!
What / Where / How questions tell the guest you want descriptive answers. Why questions tell the guest, subconsciously, that you want emotional answers. Ask the right questions, and you’ll get the right answers.
Works like a charm.
WHEN THE INTERVIEW IS OVER
Just before calling “Cut!,” but when all my questions are done, I always ask the guest: “Is there a question I should have asked that I did not?” This gives them a chance to reflect to see if they want to add, or modify anything. About a quarter of the time, the guest will suggest a great question that I hadn’t thought of.
When the interview is over, the very first words out of your mouth, after “Cut!” should be to the guest. Even if they were a train-wreck, congratulate them on doing a great job. Let them know how good they looked on camera. Reassure them that they did a good job.
While there is a fine line between flattery and down-right lying, telling a guest they were terrible won’t improve your interview. So, you might as well make them feel good as they leave the set.
Only after the guest is gone should you discuss technical issues with the crew.
NOTE: The exception to this is if there is an audio or video problem which occurs during an interview. In which case, I instruct the crew to stop the interview at the end of a guest’s answer so that we can fix the problem. Don’t interrupt the guest during an answer, because it will destroy their concentration and make them all tense again, because they will feel the problem is their fault.
An interview is a formalized process of sharing information with an audience within a very limited time. When you do your homework, set a goal, write down questions, make your guest feel comfortable and ask questions that generate solid answers, both you and your viewers will benefit. And your guests will think you are a genius!
Visit our website to see Final Cut Pro Training & more!
13 Responses to Interviewers: Ask the Right Questions← Older Comments
Excellent Larry. As the chairman of Alaska’s Society for Technology in Education’s iDidaContest (which started 14 years ago as iDidaMovie) and an avid (no pun intended) photographer and videographer I’d love to see you do one of your workshops in Alaska. ASTE’s contest is a statewide event open to students K – 12, undergraduates and adults as well. We now have 6 categories, but iDidaDoc (umentary), iDidaMovie and iDidaPhoto are ones which would benefit from your expertise.
We always turn off the tally lights, which can mesmerize/traumatize a subject.
As part of the warm-up, I reassure the subject and try to lighten things up. I tell them I get paid to make people look GOOD – not bad. If I think it will help the individual relax, I’ll show them a monitor shot of how we’ve lit and framed them to make them look attractive… then the monitors get hidden from the subject, so as not to distract. A joke I often tell them is: “I don’t charge people to record… I charge them to ERASE.” This gets a smile every time.
That warm-up time before the serious questions begin may be the only time you can get some cut-aways and iso shots of the hands, the feet, or just them smiling and nodding. make sure the camera op takes advantage of that, plus taking a minute to capture room tone for the edit.
Doing this a long time, you get an ear for the pattern of a person’s speech, and many people, when explaining something, talk more or less in paragraphs. If you are a very skilled shooter, you can hear when the subject is about to take a pause for air, or for effect – and in that moment, manually snap-zoom/re-frame the shot tighter or wider. Nowadays, a technique gaining popularity with 2K and 4K shoots is to leave the camera framed wide and artificially “punch-in” in post when and wherever you want a close-up or medium shot, because you have the extra pixels to “waste”. This isn’t exactly the same look as a lens zoom or camera dolly, and not everybody likes it, but for one-person bands working in unfamiliar territory, it can be a help.
Some people don’t understand “put the question into your answer”, so I run a practice drill where I let them ask me: “What’s you favorite ice cream?” I then show how a one-word answer like “vanilla” is non-sequitur and doesn’t help us… but then we try it a second time and I say: “Well, I like rocky road ice cream – BECAUSE – it has all these different textures going on, between the ice cream, the nuts, the chocolate, each bite you take is a little different from the last one..” and then they get the idea.
These are all excellent ideas. Thanks!